First-Generation FR-S, BRZ and 86 Rear Bumper Covers: Badge, Facelift and 2019 BRZ Identification

Supported Subaru service chain: 57704CA010 -> 57704CA011. This is not presented as unchanged plug-and-play interchange: Subaru bulletin 12-250-18 says 57704CA011 and corresponding inner mudguards began with 2019MY and requires specified trimming of earlier 2013-2018 BRZ inner mudguards plus 57756CA020NN arch caps when the new face is installed. Supported retainer chains are SU003-01503 -> SU003-08223 RH, SU003-01504 -> SU003-08224 LH, 57707CA100 -> 57707CA101 RH, 57707CA110 -> 57707CA111 LH and 57707FJ190 / 57707FJ200 -> 57707FJ201 lower. SU003-01494 and SU003-06836 are separate Scion FR-S and Toyota 86 face identities, not a claimed supersession or cross-badge interchange.

Start with the VIN, US badge and model year, then inspect the molded face and its attachment parts. Use SU003-01494 only for the checked 2013-2016 Scion FR-S branch and SU003-06836 only for the checked 2017-2020 Toyota 86 branch; Toyota documented a new, more sculpted 2017 rear bumper with an integrated aerodynamic diffuser. Keep both Toyota branches separate even when a seller says FR-S/BRZ/86. For BRZ, 57704CA010 is the original 2013-2018 face and 57704CA011 is the 2019-production design/service replacement; fitting 57704CA011 to an earlier BRZ requires the Subaru bulletin's mudguard and arch-cap work. A bare face is paint-required/unpainted and normally does not prove inclusion of retainers, tow-eye caps, inner mudguards, beam, absorber, center backup lamp, wiring, emblems or an accessory diffuser. The visible center triangle is a backup-lamp assembly, often misnamed reflector, rear fog or third brake light in listings. E5610CA000 is an add-on BRZ rear under diffuser, not the molded lower section of every factory bumper. Rear Scion, Toyota and Subaru deck-lid badges can be changed and are not interchange evidence.

Checked replacement paths include bare genuine faces, professionally paint-matched genuine faces, used take-off faces and repair-industry replacement covers. None is treated as one universal FR-S/BRZ/86 shell. Order by exact factory face identity and inspect mounting tabs, wheel-arch holes, exhaust openings, lower molded shape and whether repairers folded or heat-formed the cover for freight. E5610CA000 and aftermarket diffuser/underskirt products are separate overlays; they do not turn the wrong badge/year face into a verified fit. Parking-sensor cuts and special aero attachments remain outside this guide.

US first-generation coupes only. Match VIN, badge and model year before paint: SU003-01494 is the checked 2013-2016 Scion FR-S face, SU003-06836 the checked 2017-2020 Toyota 86 face, 57704CA010 the original 2013-2018 BRZ face and 57704CA011 the 2019-production BRZ design/service replacement. Subaru's earlier-BRZ retrofit requires its mudguard trimming and arch-cap procedure; do not hide gaps with adhesive or omit required caps. No cross-badge or Toyota pre-/post-facelift interchange is promised. The center triangle is a separate backup lamp, not proof of cover fitment, and E5610CA000 is an optional BRZ under-diffuser accessory. Verify every retainer, cap, mudguard, tab, beam/absorber and lamp actually included before paint. Follow current collision-repair information and use trained body/paint help where needed.

Supersede reviewed 23 unique research sources for this guide. 11 also appear above as a seller or official action and are not repeated here; 12 additional citations follow.

Research last verified 2026-07-27.

1. Pressroom toyota — 2017 toyota 86 is affordable fundamental sports carOpen source
2. Pressroom toyota — toyota 86 nyias 2016Open source
3. Pressroom toyota — scion transition toyotaOpen source
4. NHTSA — MC 10145074 9999Open source
5. Toyotapartsdeal — rear bumper bumper stayOpen source
6. Toyotapartsdeal — rear bumper bumper stayOpen source
7. Subaru Parts Deal — rear bumperOpen source
8. Subaru Parts Deal — rear bumperOpen source
9. Subaru Parts Deal — lamp rearOpen source
10. Toyotapartsdeal — toyota lens body compl su003 02528Open source
11. Parts subaru — 57707FJ201Open source
12. Parts subaru — E5610CA000Open source